The Promise
by Motherlode · 19 November 2026 · Crime & Thriller
Sarah opens her door to find Mike, whom she hasn't seen in 25 years, standing before her. He brings a mysterious photo of his missing sister Sam, sent anonymously, and begs Sarah to help him uncover what happened back then. The story flashes back to summer 1984, where Sarah and her friend Anja chat in a small café, just before fate would change everything.
Chapter 1
"Half an hour early," Sarah thought as she walked to the front door. "She's half an hour early." She couldn't remember the last time that had happened. Not with Anja. A sarcastic remark was already on the tip of her tongue as she yanked the door open. At first she didn't recognise him, but then she froze. "This can't be. Mike, this can't be…" "Hello, Sarah. It wasn't exactly easy to find you." He smiled uncertainly. She struggled to compose herself. This couldn't be possible. There stood Mike. When had she last seen him? It had to be at least 25 years ago. "Will you let me in?" he asked. "Oh, of course. Come in." They went into the living room, and Mike looked around. He stepped up to the photo wall with a look of surprise and studied the pictures. "Yes, Mike, that's the two of us. I still have the photos," said Sarah quietly. He examined one of the photos more closely. "I remember exactly when it was taken. It was exactly two days before Sam disappeared." He looked at her sadly. It was strange. She hadn't seen him in so long, and yet that familiarity was still there. "I really wanted to see you, but Sam is the main reason why it had to be now." He reached into his coat pocket and pulled out a photograph. Then he handed it to her. It showed a young girl with long blonde hair. She was walking along a dirt path. It seemed as though someone had called her name, because she had turned her head to answer that person. She was laughing happily. It was clearly an older photograph. "That's a lovely photo of Sam," said Sarah. "Did you take it?" "No, Sarah," he answered, and his voice sounded desperate. "Someone sent it to me in a letter. The clothes she's wearing in the photo are exactly what she had on the day she disappeared." He turned the picture over. On the back was a date. 18.04.1985. Sarah was shocked. "Please help me," he said. "I need to know what happened back then." There it was again, that plea, stirring a memory inside her. The memory of a promise they had made to each other long ago.
Chapter 2 July 1984 "This strawberry milkshake is so delicious," Anja sighed with pleasure, then continued: "Now, back to Thomas." "Okay, Thomas from the parallel class, but not the one with the red hair," Sarah said with a smile. "No, he has dark hair," Anja laughed, tossing her napkin onto the table. "Ah, sorry, Anja. Everything moves a bit too fast with you. I can't keep up anymore." "Doesn't matter anyway. When is it ever going to happen with you?" "What do you mean?" "Come on, Sarah. Boys, being in love…" The music from the jukebox was far too loud, but neither of them minded. Deine blauen Augen by Ideal. Sarah liked that song. She also liked the little café with its colourful chairs and round tables. She even liked the smell of coffee and chips. They came here often, always at the same table. It was one of their favourite spots. "I just don't rush into things." "You'll probably wait until we're already married with children." Sarah had to laugh. "Could well be. At least I won't have any regrets that way." Sarah didn't know that her life would soon change.
Chapter 3
Sarah lifted the last moving box out of the car and carried it into the stairwell of her new building. There was no lift, and the flat was on the third floor. Not exactly fun. Before she reached the second floor, she heard the voices of three teenagers standing in front of one of the flat doors. She was just trying to slip past them as unobtrusively as possible when one of the boys spoke to her. "Watch out!" She looked up in surprise — straight into two blue eyes and a grinning face. The boy was tall, had a heart-shaped face and blonde hair that stuck out wildly in every direction. "What?" "You're about to walk into the wall." "Oh, thanks." She noticed the blood rushing to her cheeks. "You're new here?" "Is it that obvious?" "Kind of. I'm Mike." "Sarah." "Welcome, Sarah." "Come on, Mike. You can flirt later!" one of the other boys called out. Sarah felt even more blood rush to her cheeks and hurried on. "Well then, see you later, Sarah," she heard him say. After she had unpacked the box, she lay down on the bed and stared at the ceiling. Mike. Mike with the blue eyes. The most beautiful blue eyes of all. Yes, see you later then, she thought, and had to smile. The telephone rang and Sarah reached for the receiver. "So, have you settled in yet?" came Anja's voice. "I just unpacked the last box." "And? Any interesting neighbours?" "Hmm." "What do you mean, hmm?" "Well, a rather cute neighbour with the most incredibly blue eyes." "Seriously? And that's coming from you?" "Yes, Anja, from me!" Sarah laughed. "I can't wait to see how that develops." "Neither can I," said Sarah. And she really meant it.
Chapter 4
When Sarah went down to collect her post from the entrance hall the following afternoon, she suddenly heard a voice behind her. "You must be Mrs Berger's daughter." She flinched slightly and turned around. "I beg your pardon?" "The new people from the third floor." Behind her stood an older man who was going bald. He was wearing a light blue work coat and holding a key in his hand. "Yes, I'm Sarah." "Sarah, that's a lovely name. I'm the caretaker, Mr Krüger. I live on the first floor." "Do come and have a cup of tea sometime, when you have a moment." Absolutely not, Sarah thought, and quickly walked on, back towards the stairs. "There you are, Sarah," she suddenly heard a voice say, and she looked up. Mike was standing on the landing. "Well now, Mr Krüger, are you inviting young girls in for tea again?" Irritated and grumbling to himself, the man walked past them and disappeared into the first floor. "You alright?" Mike asked. "Yes, thanks, Mike. He's really creepy." "Best to stay out of his way," he said, giving her an encouraging nod before heading towards the front door.
Chapter 5 Since Sarah hadn't changed schools, the move wasn't quite as hard on her. She had quickly settled into the building, and the anticipation of the upcoming summer holidays made things even easier. Every now and then she would run into Mike in the stairwell. Sometimes she would also see him when he and his friends were messing around down in the courtyard. Occasionally she could even hear their laughter when she was sitting in her room with the window on the latch. From there she could watch the group. The courtyard seemed to be their meeting place. "So what's happening with the new neighbour with the amazing blue eyes?" Anja asked one day on the way home. Sarah told her about the encounters in the courtyard. "Every evening? Oh, I have to see this, Sarah! I'll come over tonight. I wanted to ask you something anyway, about the maths homework." "You mean copy it." "I'd say we're comparing notes," Anja laughed. Of course Anja hadn't arrived by seven. That wasn't unusual, though. So Sarah took one last critical look in the bathroom mirror. Brush her shoulder-length dark blonde hair one more time, and maybe put on some lip gloss? Perhaps she really should try a new hairstyle sometime. One with layers, like Nena? The doorbell pulled her out of her thoughts. "There you finally are! Come in." "I think the group is already down in the courtyard," Anja chattered excitedly. "I walked past them on the way up. Come on, forget the maths homework, let's go down!" Sarah laughed. "But I do want to show you my room first," she said, pulling her friend by the arm into the flat. When they stepped into the courtyard a little later, the warm evening air greeted them. You could smell the scent of the linden trees, and above the rooftops lay the deep blue summer sky. The group was leaning against the low wall by the playground. Mike noticed the two of them straight away and waved. Anja leaned towards Sarah and whispered, "That must be him. Not bad." "No, not bad, is he?" Sarah murmured back, noticing that the heat was rising to her face again in a suspiciously familiar way. "Hello, neighbour, have you settled in alright?" said Mike. "Hi, Mike. Yes — this is my friend Anja." "Hi, Anja," Mike greeted her warmly. Then he turned to his friends to introduce them. "The one with the wild curls is Sascha, and the not-quite-so-loud one is Christian." Then he added, "I was starting to worry that our dear caretaker Krüger had frightened Sarah so badly she'd want to move out again." He told them about the encounter in the stairwell. "Yeah, he's creepy. Best to give him a wide berth," said Sascha. "Definitely," Sarah resolved. Time flew by. The lanterns in the courtyard had come on by now, and from one of the windows came the quiet sound of music. They talked about the upcoming summer holidays and about who had what plans. "I'm going to spend the whole day sleeping or eating," said Sascha. Mike laughed loudly. "I'll believe the eating part straight away, but you'll definitely be the first one showing up at my door every day." The whole group had to laugh. Then Mike turned to Sarah. "By the way, we're here in the courtyard almost every evening at seven. Everyone comes whenever they feel like it. You're always welcome." "Thanks, Mike. We'd love to come," she said, feeling a little self-conscious. When Anja eventually said she ought to be heading home, Sarah was surprised by how late it had got.
Indicated by the author: partly created with AI support.
Read in the app, leave a resonance, discover more stories.