Deutsch

The Grace of Forgetting

by maxjoread · 14 November 2026 · Short Stories

A narrator discovers a mysterious book that promises to erase past events, and when he undoes his father's death, he creates a world in which he himself never existed. The story explores the paradoxical bond between grief, loss, and love through a quietly devastating fantasy premise. It ends with the narrator attempting to undo his mistake, leaving the outcome ambiguous.

Open on Fireside →Read in the app, leave a resonance, discover more stories.

The first person I removed from the world was already dead.

I didn't yet know, back then, that it was possible.

In an old book I had found a sentence whose author had left no name:

What has never happened can make no one unhappy.

Beneath it was an instruction.

Write down the event you wish to unmake. Cross it out. Burn the page.

I took it for one of those strange pieces of advice that people give each other when they cannot bear what cannot be changed.

Still, I wrote:

My father died on the fourteenth of September.

I crossed out the sentence.

Then I burned the paper.

The next morning, my father was alive.

That should have made me happy.

But he didn't recognise me.

It emerged that my father had never died.

He had also never married.

My mother had never met him. Photographs of his travels hung in his house, and in his study stood books he had never owned in the life I remembered.

I asked him about his son.

He said he had no children.

I wanted to contradict him, but what could I have shown him?

My birth was not recorded.

The people I had grown up with did not remember me. My childhood home was still standing, but a strange family lived in it.

Only I knew that it had once been different.

Then I understood the mistake.

I had not prevented my father's death.

I had created a world in which that death had never existed.

And such a world had no reason to have brought me into being either.

I sought out the book again.

This time I read it in full.

It contained no stories, only brief accounts by people who had tried to escape their fate.

A man had crossed out the day of his greatest humiliation. The following morning he was admired everywhere, but could not recall a single person he himself admired.

A woman had erased the night she had lost her daughter. Afterwards she possessed all her memories of the child, but no longer the capacity to miss her.

At the end of each account stood the same sentence:

The wish was granted.

Nowhere did it say that anyone had become happy.

On the last page I found a remark:

The human being asks for a life without pain and does not understand that he is often asking for a life without love. For whoever can never lose anything has perhaps never possessed anything either.

I read that sentence for a long time.

Then I closed the book.

It was beautiful.

And it was cruel.

But above all it was useless, because I wanted my father back, not an insight about love.

That night I resolved to undo my mistake.

I wrote:

My father did not die on the fourteenth of September.

I crossed out the sentence and burned the page.

By morning my father was dead again.

My birth was recorded in the registers.

People recognised me.

Everything was as before.

Except for one small thing.

I remembered both of my father's lives.

The father who had raised me and died.

And the man who had never learned of my existence and who by now was perhaps living on somewhere.

I even remembered his travels, though I had never accompanied him.

One day a conversation came back to me that he had held during one of those journeys.

It had taken place on a train.

An unknown man had explained to him that every possibility was real somewhere, so long as a person remembered it.

My father had laughed.

Then he had asked what became of the possibilities that no one kept in memory any longer.

The stranger had answered:

"They wait."

That was all I knew of that conversation.

But it unsettled me that I could remember it at all.

For my father had never held that conversation.

At least not in the world I lived in.

Before long the foreign memories began to come of their own accord.

I remembered cities that did not exist.

A woman I had loved, though I had never learned her name.

A staircase in a house with no upper floors.

And finally my own death.

It happened on a Tuesday.

I had grown old and was sitting by the window.

When I died I felt neither pain nor fear.

Only regret.

Not that my life was ending.

But that I would never find out who had told it.

This memory was so vivid that I could barely sleep for three days.

For it confronted me with a question I had been avoiding until then:

If I could remember a life that had not taken place – why should my present life be real in any particular sense?

I opened the book a third time.

Now it contained only a single account.

My own.

It began with the sentence:

The first person I removed from the world was already dead.

I turned the pages.

Everything was in there.

My father's return.

The foreign memories.

The train.

The conversation.

Even my thoughts about life and reality.

I read until I reached the place where I was now sitting.

Then followed a line I had not yet written:

At this point he understands that he is not the author of the book.

That was no great revelation.

After all, I had found it.

But the next sentence was worse:

He is not its reader either.

I paused.

A book can be closed, I thought. A book can be burned. You can set it aside and go on living.

I tried to shut it.

My hands would not obey.

On the following page it said:

He will now attempt to leave the book.

I stood up.

Immediately the room became indistinct.

The table lost its colour. The walls grew paler, as though someone were drawing the ink out of them.

I took a step.

The floor ended.

Not at a door or a precipice.

It simply ended.

Beyond it was nothing.

I looked back.

The book was still lying on the table.

Except that the table was now standing on a white page.

And I was on the next one.

At last I understood.

Someone had invented me.

Perhaps out of boredom.

Perhaps out of grief.

Perhaps to explain a thought he could not think through to the end himself.

My father had not died.

He had never lived.

The two worlds I remembered were nothing but two possibilities that a foreign mind had contemplated for a few moments.

It was unbearable.

Not that I had been invented.

But that I knew it.

For even an invented person can suffer, as long as the story compels him to.

I searched desperately for a way out.

Then I remembered the first sentence of the old book.

What has never happened can make no one unhappy.

I understood what I had to do.

If someone had invented me, then I too could invent someone.

And if I created a person who read me, my story might go on living in that person's reality.

I began to imagine a reader.

I gave him no face.

No name.

No past.

It was enough for me that he could read.

I imagined how he would be curious at first.

How he might find the beginning strange.

How he would skim over some sentences.

And how he would finally pause at a certain point, because he noticed that the story was no longer only about me.

It was about him.

The idea filled me with a hope I had long believed lost.

For now there was someone outside my story.

Someone who could end it.

Someone who was not compelled to read the next page.

And perhaps that was the only freedom ever granted to a human being: not the power to change one's life, but the possibility of not continuing a story.

I wanted to thank this unknown reader.

But when I tried to write the corresponding words, I noticed they were already on the page.

Beneath them stood one last sentence:

He believed he had invented a reader.

I waited for what would follow.

It did not appear.

For the first time since my story had begun, something happened that was not written down.

A hand drew close to the page.

Not mine.

It came from outside.

Slowly it descended toward the paper.

I wanted to call out to it not to stop.

That it must not leave me alone.

For as long as it was reading, I was still there.

But the hand reached for the book.

And I understood what it was going to do.

In that moment I wanted only one thing:

For the reader not to forget me.

Not out of love.

Not out of pity.

But because I knew by now what becomes of the possibilities that no one remembers any longer.

They wait.

And some of them wait so long that they have forgotten what for.

Grief & LossMemory & the PastGuilt & ConsequenceLove and Its CostIdentity & Existence
Open on Fireside

Read in the app, leave a resonance, discover more stories.

More stories on Fireside →